Context and Background
The report titled "Community-led Place Stewardship" was published in January 2025 by the Community Land Trust Network of England and Wales, the European Community Land Trust Network, and Dark Matter Labs, with support from the Laudes Foundation. This report aims to explore and propose transformative management practices for large housing-led sites in England and Europe, emphasizing sustainable community stewardship.
Challenges in Housing Management
The report highlights a significant shift in the management of large housing developments in the UK, where over 80% are now run by private management companies. This shift has resulted in poor service delivery and a lack of accountability, leading to widespread dissatisfaction among residents. The Competition and Markets Authority's 2024 study indicated that many private management arrangements fail to provide value for money, with millions of households affected. The report stresses that new models of community-led stewardship are necessary to combat these challenges.
Key Findings
The report provides insights from five pioneering case studies in England that demonstrate successful community-led stewardship models. It emphasizes the importance of engaging citizens at every stage of housing development, from planning to management. The research reveals that inclusive governance structures, where community organizations play a key role, can significantly improve the quality of life in neighborhoods and ensure long-term sustainability.
Community Land Trusts (CLTs)
Community Land Trusts are identified as a viable model for community-led stewardship. These non-profit organizations ensure that land and housing remain affordable and accessible to local communities. The report notes that CLTs are rooted in democratic governance, allowing residents to have a direct say in decision-making processes. The Community Land Trust Network's 2023 report highlighted the potential for CLTs to steward approximately 278,000 homes in the UK, showcasing their scalability and effectiveness.
🇺 European Context
The report also explores community-led stewardship practices across Europe, comparing various models and governance structures. Countries like Denmark and Switzerland feature strong community governance frameworks that prioritize tenant democracy and long-term affordability. The report suggests that lessons from these European models can inform and enhance community-led initiatives in the UK.
Recommendations for Future Stewardship Models
To foster effective community-led stewardship, the report provides several recommendations, including: 1. Establishing stewardship plans early in the development process to build trust among stakeholders. 2. Utilizing digital systems for better data management to facilitate community participation. 3. Encouraging local authorities to actively support community-led initiatives through financial and regulatory frameworks. 4. Promoting research and innovation in community stewardship to improve outcomes for residents.
Conclusion
As the demand for housing continues to rise, the report underscores the urgent need for innovative management practices that empower communities. By prioritizing community-led stewardship, the report argues that it is possible to create resilient, sustainable neighborhoods that respond to the evolving needs of residents. This approach represents a significant shift from traditional management models, paving the way for more inclusive and effective governance in housing development across Europe.